Close Panel

Forum

Current User: Guest Login Register
Please consider registering

Search 
Search Forums:


 




alignment or misalignment

Add a New Topic Reply to Post
UserPost

4:12 pm
September 1, 2009


hleroy

Member

posts 9

Just a quick thought here …

I was wondering why the items in the BI-survey are all positively formulated?

If I understand the theory correctly, it would seem that perceived misalignment would be a more powerful predictor?

(easier to keep promises rather rectify a broken promise)

I cannot find the exact reason for this in the literature.

6:12 pm
September 1, 2009


TonySimons

Member

posts 16

Negatively worded items in general often load differently than positively worded items.  Though the theory on scale development advocates using them, you will find most recent scales do not include negatively worded items –  or only use items of one or the other type.  That said, I would be open to using negatively worded items if they work…  i suspect that the key to doing so while maintaining good statistical properties would simply be to develop a longer scale… a luxury I have not afforded myself.  I wanted to stay conservative while the construct is still being established.

4:08 pm
September 2, 2009


hleroy

Member

posts 9

I may not have been clear in my previous post.


I am not referring to a mixture of positive & negative but rather letting the PBI consist of all negative items.


My reasons for suggesting this are theoretical rather than methodological: is  perceived misalignment not going to be a better predictor than perceived alignment?

Is it not more theoretical sound to measure promises broken than promises kept.

In most of the articles I read I find referral to perceived misalignment as having determental effects while perceived alignment just serves the status quo.

8:17 am
September 3, 2009


TonySimons

Member

posts 16

You raise an empirical question.  I have conceived BI in positive terms, but either way might work.  Test out the contrasting approaches, to see which predicts better..

Add a New Topic Reply to Post


Reply to Topic: alignment or misalignment

NOTE: New Posts are subject to administrator approval before being displayed

Guest Name (Required):

Guest EMail (Required):

Guest URL (required)

Math Required!
What is the sum of: 9 + 3        (Required)

Topic Reply:


 

About the Integrity Dividend forum

Currently Online:

5 Guests

Maximum Online: 8

Forums:

Groups: 3

Forums: 9

Topics: 13

Posts: 34

Members:

There are 29 members

There are 1 guests

Top Posters:

TonySimons – 16

hleroy – 9

kbasik – 5

Mike Palanski – 2

Jackie – 1

Eric – 0

Administrator: admin


© Simple:Press Forum – Version 3.1.4 (Build 357)  

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • Propeller